Law report No. GLW-9105 · filed November 13, 2026
Regulation & EnforcementReported case
Ofwat tightens water bonus ban as £1.7m retention deals draw fire
Ofwat bans bonuses at nine water firms for 2025-26 and speeds up a loophole review after retention payments of up to £1.7m drew criticism.
By Grace Kim4 min read775 words
Holding
- Ofwat banned bonuses at nine water companies for 2025-26; seven bans related to environmental pollution.
- Anglian Water's CEO received retention payments of up to £800,000 despite the ban.
- Ofwat flagged retention payments of £1m, £1.5m and £1.7m at Thames, Northumbrian and United Utilities.
- The banned companies would have paid £6.5m more in executive bonuses without the ban; £10m has been blocked in two years.
- Thames Water paid CEO Chris Weston a deferred bonus of £99,000 despite the ban.

By Grace Kim
Ofwat has blocked nine water companies in England and Wales from paying executive bonuses for the 2025-26 financial year and accelerated a review of the rules, warning on Thursday that large payments to bosses risk "damaging public trust". Seven of the nine bans relate to environmental pollution. The regulator said it would speed up the review over concerns that companies were deliberately "undermining" the ban.
Anglian Water drew the sharpest criticism. Ofwat singled out "retention payments" worth up to £800,000 for chief executive Mark Thurston, and said the company will face increased monitoring of its governance arrangements because of the payments.
What did Ofwat decide?
The nine companies banned from paying bonuses are Thames Water, Yorkshire Water, Anglian Water, Severn Trent Water, Southern Water, South West Water, Wessex Water and Dŵr Cymru (Welsh Water). Ofwat said they would have paid out another £6.5m to executives during the year had the ban not been in place.
Ofwat said: "The growing use of fixed so-called 'retention payments' and substantial increases in base pay without sufficient explanation or supporting evidence risks damaging public trust and creating a perception that companies are circumventing the rule."
On Anglian, the regulator said the payments to Thurston "could give the impression the company had prioritised offering executive directors a cash award in a way that would not technically breach the rule and would in practice replace the loss of PRP [performance-related pay] prohibited by it".
Beyond Anglian, Ofwat flagged potential retention payments of £1m for Thames Water's chief financial officer, £1.5m for Northumbrian Water chief executive Heidi Mottram, and £1.7m for Louise Beardmore, chief executive of United Utilities.
The takeaway: the ban's scope, not just its existence, is now the regulatory battleground.
How are companies getting around the ban?
The Labour government introduced the bonus ban last year amid public outrage over sewage leaking into Britain's rivers and seas. Yet bosses' pay has risen over the past two years despite the ban, according to Guardian analysis. Campaigners and opposition politicians argue companies are replacing banned bonuses with payments that are not formally "performance-related".
The accelerated review is understood to also consider whether payments from water companies' parent companies should fall within the ban, a move that would close one of the most common structuring routes.
Thames Water illustrates the pattern. It paid chief executive Chris Weston a previously deferred bonus of £99,000 during the year, despite the ban. Ofwat said Thames's future owners will have to fund that bonus rather than customer bills. Thames was also criticised for raising executives' base pay.
South East Water was not subject to the ban, but Ofwat said its shareholders will have to pay for future bonuses after huge supply failures left tens of thousands of households without water during the financial year. Ofwat also criticised the paucity of pay information reported by South Staffs Water.
The practical consequence for practitioners: remuneration committees at water companies must now assume that any award — retention payment, base pay rise, deferral or parent-company payment — will be scrutinised against the ban's purpose, not merely its text.
What have ministers and the regulator said?
Environment secretary Angela Eagle said she wanted to "close loopholes" so that "failure doesn't pay". She said: "People are sick of seeing water bosses profit while rivers are polluted and customers are repeatedly let down. A wide-ranging review launching today will ensure that failure doesn't pay, whatever name the payment goes by. The bonus ban was the first step. Where there are loopholes, I want them closed."
Helen Campbell, Ofwat's interim executive director for delivery, said: "It is disappointing that so many companies continue to trigger the rule through serious performance failures which has seen £10m in payments blocked in the past two years. Public trust in the water sector remains low, and executive bonuses which do not reflect performance, use of retention payments and poorly explained increases in base pay contribute to that low trust. That is why we are accelerating our review to ensure the rule better delivers the outcomes customers rightly expect."
What happens next on ownership?
Political pressure extends beyond pay. Mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham, who has said he wants to exert "more public control" over the water industry, is yet to give details. He has not decided whether to move Thames Water into temporary government ownership after years of financial struggles and mismanagement, months after suggesting he might do so.
The message from Thursday's decisions is simple: Ofwat will police the substance of pay, not its label.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
320 articles
Also before the court
- UK Weighs £5,000 Cost Cap Removal for Green Planning Challenges
- U.K. Regulator Fines Virgin Media $38 Million for Repeat Competition Breach
- Visa and Mastercard Face Potential £5bn UK Class Action Over Card Fees
- BHP Loses Bid to Overturn Interest Payment Order in Brazil Dam Case
- UK Regulator Fines Barclays Over Financial Crime Risks