Law report No. GLW-9653 · filed November 20, 2026

Human RightsReported case

EHRC chair urges calm over single-sex spaces guidance

EHRC chair Mary-Ann Stephenson urged calmer debate after reactions to EHRC guidance on biological sex raised concerns among transgender people in Scotland, including over hospital care.

By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read742 words

Holding

  1. On Thursday, the Scottish Parliament’s Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee heard evidence at Holyrood from EHRC chair Mary-Ann Stephenson and support organisations.
  2. The EHRC released its guidance earlier this year after the Supreme Court ruled that “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 referred to biological sex.
  3. Scottish Trans said at least three transgender people had avoided hospital treatment against medical advice because they feared ward placement.
  4. Stephenson rejected claims that the code excludes all trans people from public life or provides for genital checks.
  5. Scottish Trans said EHRC-referred legal advice was widely varied and often conflicting, leaving trans-inclusive organisations with substantial expense and no clear answer.
‘Take temperature down’ over guidance on single-sex spaces, head of UK equalities body urges
Plate‘Take temperature down’ over guidance on single-sex spaces, head of UK equalities body urges — Parentingupstream / pixabay

By Sophie Lindqvist

At least three transgender people have avoided hospital care against medical advice because they fear placement on a ward, the Scottish Parliament’s Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee heard on Thursday.

The committee took evidence at Holyrood on guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), the UK's equalities watchdog, about single-sex spaces (places limited by sex under the Equality Act 2010).

EHRC chair Mary-Ann Stephenson urged the public to lower the temperature after what she called misinformation about the guidance. The MSPs (members of the Scottish Parliament) also heard from support organisations.

What does the guidance follow?

The EHRC released the guidance earlier this year. It came after the UK Supreme Court ruled that “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 referred to biological sex.

That decision supplies the legal starting point for the EHRC’s code of practice. Support organisations told the committee that the reaction had affected access to leisure facilities and healthcare settings, with some transgender people declining medical attention because of uncertainty about the law.

The committee therefore heard a practical access problem, not only a contested interpretation of terminology, because ward placement and use of healthcare or leisure facilities can affect whether a person seeks care. Organisations supporting transgender people said the ruling and guidance had caused concern across Scotland.

No new interpretation emerged at the hearing. The statutory point had already been decided by the Supreme Court, while the committee focused on the guidance’s effects on services and the anxiety surrounding its implementation.

What did Mary-Ann Stephenson say?

Stephenson said the code had been described in inflated terms. She rejected claims that it excluded all trans people from public life or provided for genital checks to ensure access to services.

She said: “I think it’s incumbent on all of us to try to take the temperature down a little bit in this area.”

Stephenson also said significant numbers of transgender people, including possibly younger people, felt very anxious. She linked that anxiety to what they had believed the law allowed before the ruling showed otherwise.

Her longer account placed the dispute in context. In her view, claims about blanket exclusion and genital checks had created anxiety about matters the law and code did not address. She acknowledged that feelings were high and people were upset, but said inflated descriptions did not help.

Stephenson said the Equality Act aimed to build a society where everyone could live with dignity, access needed services and avoid discrimination. That purpose, she said, should remain central when service providers and the public discuss the code.

Why are some hospital visits a concern?

Florence Oulds, policy and public affairs coordinator at the charity Scottish Trans, said: “We are aware of at least three trans people we’ve spoken to and other trans people we’ve heard evidence from who have not gone to hospital, against medical advice, because they are concerned about where they’ll be placed on a ward.”

Oulds described that response as a common sentiment. Her evidence reached beyond the three people she had spoken with directly, because she also cited information from other transgender people. The concern was not limited to how a policy was written; it affected decisions about whether individuals would use needed healthcare.

Why do organisations dispute the code?

Oulds said the code of practice was fundamentally confusing and difficult to follow. She said the EHRC often instructs organisations to seek legal advice, but the available advice covers an extremely wide range and often completely conflicts.

Oulds said trans-inclusive organisations, meaning groups seeking to include transgender people, wanted to do the right thing, comply with the law and preserve inclusion. Those organisations had spent lots of money on legal advice without reaching a clear answer, she told the committee.

Stephenson disagreed with that interpretation. She said the code was actually quite straightforward. The committee evidence therefore records a sharp difference: one witness organisation saw confusing and conflicting guidance, while the regulator’s chair considered it clear.

What does this mean for practitioners?

For practitioners, the law and code are a map, but conflicting advice creates several routes through decisions about ward placement, access and compliance in healthcare and leisure settings. Operators must apply the Supreme Court’s interpretation to arrangements rather than assume blanket exclusion or genital checks. The evidence leaves two practical risks: inconsistent access decisions and legal spending without clarity.

via theguardian.com (Source)

Filed under

  • ehrc
  • equality-act
  • single-sex-spaces
  • transgender-rights
  • supreme-court
Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

360 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »