Law report No. GLW-3418 · filed November 19, 2026
Legal PracticeReported case
ABA Formal Opinion 526: Lawyers Must Make 'Noisy Withdrawal' in Client Fraud
ABA Formal Opinion 526, published Nov. 18, orders lawyers who learn of client fraud in deals to persuade, disclose, and make a 'noisy withdrawal' — disavowing prior work like collateral evaluations.
By Sophie Lindqvist3 min read669 words
Holding
- ABA Formal Opinion 526 was published Nov. 18.
- The opinion interprets Model Rules 4.1(b) and 1.6(b) on disclosure versus confidentiality.
- Lawyers must attempt client persuasion before disclosing a client's fraud.
- Disclosure is generally satisfied by a 'noisy withdrawal' disavowing prior work such as a collateral evaluation.
- Disclosure is limited to information necessary to avoid assisting the client's crime or fraud.
The American Bar Association published Formal Opinion 526 on Nov. 18, and it tells lawyers exactly what to do when a client lies in a loan application. The answer: withdraw, and do it loudly enough that the defrauded party knows something is wrong.
The opinion comes from the ABA's Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility. It addresses a familiar conflict. Client confidentiality protects what a lawyer knows. But a lawyer also cannot help a client commit fraud. When those duties collide, the opinion says disclosure wins — within limits.
Which rules does the opinion interpret?
The opinion reads ABA Model Rules 4.1(b) and 1.6(b) together. Rule 4.1(b) prohibits a lawyer, in representing a client, from failing to disclose a material fact when necessary to avoid assisting a client's criminal or fraudulent act. But the rule contains a carve-out. There can be no disclosure if the "disclosure is prohibited by Rule 1.6."
Rule 1.6 generally prohibits a lawyer from revealing client information. It contains an exception, though. A lawyer may disclose if she believes the revelation will prevent a client from committing a crime or fraud that will cause substantial injury to a third party. If that threshold is met, Rule 1.6(b) permits disclosure.
Think of the two rules as a lock and a key. Rule 4.1(b) creates the duty to speak. Rule 1.6(b) decides whether that duty can actually be carried out without breaching confidentiality.
What does the opinion say lawyers must do?
The opinion works through a concrete example. A lawyer represents a borrower in a lending transaction. The borrower asks the lawyer to give the lender an evaluation of whether the borrower has adequate collateral. The lawyer provides it. Later, the lawyer learns the borrower has no such collateral at all.
The first step is persuasion, not disclosure. The lawyer should try to convince the client to come clean and rectify the situation. If the client refuses, the opinion says the lawyer is required to disclose that material fact under Rule 4.1(b).
That disclosure usually forces a second move. The lawyer must withdraw from the representation under Rule 1.16(a). And the withdrawal often must be a "noisy withdrawal" — a disengagement that notifies the lender or defrauded party that there is a problem, without spelling out every detail.
How much can the lawyer actually say?
The opinion keeps the disclosure narrow. It explains that "the lawyer's disclosure obligation will generally be satisfied by withdrawing or disavowing the lawyer's previous evaluation that served to further the client's criminal or fraudulent activity."
The reason is proportionality. Disclosure under Rule 4.1(b), the opinion states, "is limited to the amount of information necessary to avoid 'assisting' in a client's crime or fraud."
So the lawyer does not get a license to dump the client's file on the lender. The duty is to undo the assistance already given. Disavowing the earlier collateral evaluation does that. A quiet resignation does not, because the lender would keep relying on a statement the lawyer now knows is false.
What does this mean for practitioners?
The practical sequence is now clear. Convince the client first. If persuasion fails, disclose the material fact. Withdraw from the matter. And make the withdrawal noisy enough to signal the problem to the injured party.
Transactional lawyers face the highest exposure here. Any professional who has delivered an opinion, evaluation or certification in a deal — and then learns the underlying facts are false — sits squarely inside this opinion. Waiting for the deal to close, or resigning silently, is no longer a defensible middle path under the ABA's reading of the Model Rules.
The opinion is persuasive authority, not binding law. State regulators adopt their own versions of the Model Rules, and those versions can differ. But Formal Opinion 526 gives lawyers a roadmap that regulators and courts will treat as the baseline analysis.
via abajournal.com (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
360 articles
Also before the court
- Lawyers Criticise New Disclosure Rules as Unworkable
- Solicitor Tribunal Clears Lawyer Who Misled Client Three Times
- UK law firms to be told to hand over client account interest
- AI Is Now Mainstream in Law — But Clients Are Not Told, Survey Finds
- SRA Moves to Stop Solicitors Keeping Interest on Client Money